Peel potatoes and cut them into quarters. Leave them in cold water until you are ready to cook them. (For extra ease keep them in the pot you are going to cook them in)
When you are ready to cook, bring the water to a boil and then simmer uncovered for an hour (more or less time may be needed depending on the size of the quartered potatoes).
When a pairing knife can easily go through the center of the potato it is cooked.
Strain out the water and return the potatoes to the stove.
In a small saucepot add the ½ and ½ and butter. Bring to a simmer.
Use a ricer to remove the lumps from the potato and return the potatoes back to the pot.
Slowly incorporate the heated liquids into the potato and stir with a rubber spatula.
Add the salt a little at a time and finish with cracked pepper and arugula.
Tips on the Perfect Potato:
Try buying Golden Potatoes (Yukons) instead of Russets. They have a smooth golden outside and are much creamier inside. You can cook them like your regular mashed russet potato.
For those of you who don’t know, when you boil them after peeling them, make sure you cut them into equal pieces so that the potatoes, no matter what type, cook at the same rate. When the potatoes are finished cooking, pour out the water and put them back on the stove for a few more minutes. It will help cook out the water. You can check to see if the potatoes are done by piercing a small pairing knife through the center of the potato.
Next, heat the cream and butter. These liquids incorporate into the potatoes easier if they’re hot.
While the liquids are heating mash the potatoes. You can use one of two tools to do this…1. A Ricer around $150, (I just bought one and I love it). It turns the potato into rice looking form, which you can easily mash and it gets rid of all lumps. Or 2. Potato masher around $20. (Spend a little extra and buy the one with a rubber handle, you will thank me later) This is cheaper than the ricer but you don’t have near the same results.
As you are mashing the potatoes, add the butter and cream mixture (low fat milk for those of you who are watching the calories and for those who want no calories try chicken stock, for those who are vegetarian try vegetable stock, and if you are looking to add a super food to your meal try mashed sweet potatoes instead of the Yukon Gold). Make sure at this point you’re adding in the salt; always add more than you think.
*Potatoes take a lot of salt to release their delicate flavor. If you are not comfortable with adding a lot of salt you can do a test. Put a scoop of potatoes into a small bowl and add salt until you get the taste you are looking for and then mimic the taste in the larger batch. It will help boost your confidence without the risk of ruining the whole bowl.